The Finish Line Inc versus Shoe Carnival Inc Head to Head Compare

Date Published:

This is a head to head compare of The Finish Line Inc (NASDAQ:FINL) and Shoe Carnival Inc (NASDAQ:SCVL) . We will compare the two companies on revenue growth, earnings, revenue per employee, operating margins, free cash flow and valuation. The head to head compare assigns 100 points in total.

Before we dive into the analysis, we will look at the stock returns for each company over the last three months, six months and the last year. The stock returns do not impact the head to head compare scores which are focused on the fundamentals of each company, but ultimately stock returns are are still a critical piece to a full analysis and compare.

Stock Returns
Symbol 3-Months 6-Months One-Year Fundamentals
FINL -8.6% -24.9% -19.3%
SCVL +1.1% -0.3% -0.3%

Shoe Carnival Inc has a higher fundamental rating then The Finish Line Inc which has an impact on the head-to-head comparison. The CML Star Rating is an objective, quantifiable measure of a company's operating and financial condition. The rating is computed by measuring numerous elements of the company's current financial data and their associated changes over time.

Now, let's dive into the two companies to compare them.

➤ Income Statement
First we turn to the income statement and compare revenue, earnings and revenue per employee for both companies. We note that simple revenue comparisons do not impact the rating.

The Finish Line Inc has larger revenue in the last year than Shoe Carnival Inc. Raw revenue comps do not affect the head to head rating.

SCVL is showing a profit while FINL has negative earnings over the last year.

Net Income

SCVL generates larger revenue per employee ($249,000) than FINL ($203,000), but not enough to affect the comparison rating.

Revenue per Employee
($ Millions)

➤ Margins
Next we create some derived metrics to compare the the amount of revenue earned per dollar of expense and the amount of free cash flow earned per dollar of revenue. Margins are one of the fairest ways to compare companies since they remove some of the bias of large versus small numbers.

Shoe Carnival Inc generates $1.06 in revenue for every $1 of expense, while The Finish Line Inc generates an operating loss with just $0.95 in revenue per $1 of expense.

Revenue per Dollar of Expense

SCVL generates $0.03 in levered free cash flow for every $1 of revenue, substantially higher than FINL's $0.02.

Free Cash Flow
per Dollar of Revenue

➤ Growth
Finally we compare the financial metrics related to growth: revenue growth rates and price to sales.

Both companies are growing revenue. The Finish Line Inc is growing revenue massively faster than Shoe Carnival Inc.

Revenue Growth

For every $1 in revenue, the stock market prices in $0.36 in market cap for FINL and $0.49 in market cap for SCVL.

Price to Sales

Shoe Carnival Inc (NASDAQ:SCVL)
The Finish Line Inc (NASDAQ:FINL) : 61 to 39